Lots of opinions given here as absolutes. I see a lot of this on our forum. This isn't specific to this thread. What happened to the day when members would say, in my experience, I've seen this, or I like this one because, your experience may vary?
These conversations most often end the same way, with one member being louder than the other. One fanboy/toady or another jumps in to the fray to back one opinion, or the other, and at the end of the day the thread has answered little and has proven less.
I see a lot of opinions given and little evidence to support the opinions. Having witnessed one thing or the other even multiple times doesn't statistically mean anything with the sampling size we see here. I don't know of anyone buying all of these products to compare with the others and doing 500 launches with each to see they perform or hold up.
Reading it on the internet is worth exactly what you paid to do so. Life is good, be happy.